Skip to Content

We Have a Safety Consultant. Here Is What the Act Still Leaves With You.

Most South African businesses that retain a health and safety consultant have made a sound decision, and most consultants do good work
October 4, 2026 by
Philip de Witt

In brief

Most South African businesses that retain a health and safety consultant have made a sound decision, and most consultants do good work. But the Occupational Health and Safety Act does not move any duty onto the consultant. Section 8 places the duty to provide a safe workplace on the employer, section 16(1) makes the chief executive officer answerable for seeing that the employer's duties are discharged, and section 16(3) says in terms that this does not relieve the employer of any responsibility or liability under the Act. [1][2][3] The CEO may assign duties under section 16(2), but only to a person "under his control", who then acts "subject to the control and directions of the chief executive officer". [1][2] A consultant advises; the business decides, funds, instructs and closes. This article sets out exactly what the Act lets you hand over, what it keeps with you, and five questions that tell you, in an afternoon, whether your arrangement covers the part the Act leaves behind.

What the Act lets you hand over

The Act allows a good deal of delegation, and it is worth being precise about it, because the objection "we already have someone" is usually true.

Section 16(2) allows the chief executive officer to assign "any duty" contemplated in section 16(1) to a person under the CEO's control. [1] There is no limit on the number of such assignments, and commentary consistently describes the section 16(2) appointee as responsible for health and safety in the area of the business assigned to them. [2][3] That is how a managing director legitimately spreads the work across a plant manager, a branch manager and a site supervisor.

The Act also recognises outside parties. Section 1 defines a "mandatary" as including "an agent, a contractor or a subcontractor for work", without derogating from that person's own status as an employer. [1] An employer can therefore bring in outside help, and the Act has a vocabulary for it.

What the Act does not do is treat delegation as a transfer of accountability. Two phrases carry that, and both are in section 16 itself.

What the Act keeps with you

Section 16(2) opens with the words "Without derogating from his responsibility or liability in terms of subsection (1)". [1] The CEO who assigns a duty still holds it. Section 16(3) then adds that subsection (1) does not, subject to section 37, "relieve an employer of any responsibility or liability under this Act". [1][2] Commentary on the section reduces it to one line: a person may delegate responsibility, but not accountability. [2]

The second limit is the phrase "any person under his control". [1] A section 16(2) assignee acts subject to the CEO's control and directions. An external consultant is engaged under a services contract, usually visits on a schedule and usually does not control the budget, the workforce or the production line. One South African practitioner, writing on whether an appointed safety officer takes over management's liability, answers plainly that it does not, that an external consultant "can advise and assist, but the client remains the employer", and that a section 16(2) appointment of a safety officer is possible "only where the person is under the CEO's control and has genuine authority over the duties being assigned". [3] Whether a particular consultant could ever satisfy that test turns on the facts of the engagement, and we do not state it as a rule. What the text makes clear is that the default position runs the other way.

The third limit is section 37. Where an employee does or omits something that would be an offence for the employer, the employer is presumed to have done it, unless the employer proves three things, including that "all reasonable steps were taken" to prevent it. [1] The section adds that the fact that the employer "issued instructions forbidding" the act "shall not, in itself, be accepted as sufficient proof" of reasonable steps. [1][3] Section 37(2) applies the same presumption to a mandatary, except where the parties "have agreed in writing to the arrangements and procedures between them to ensure compliance". [1]

Read together, the three provisions describe a business that may get as much help as it likes and still has to show, in its own records, that it acted on that help.

Where the gap usually sits

None of this is a criticism of consultants. The consultant identifies the hazard, drafts the appointment, runs the risk assessment and writes the report. That work is usually accurate on the day it is done. The gap sits in what happens afterwards, which is the part the Act leaves with the business.

A finding is raised on a visit. Closing it needs a purchase order, a contractor, a training booking or a manager's decision, and those happen inside the business, usually by email. The consultant returns a month or a quarter later and finds some items closed and some not, and the evidence for the closed ones is in somebody's inbox. Meanwhile a first aider resigns, a branch opens, a forklift's examination falls due, and none of those events is routed to the consultant, because they are payroll, property and procurement events, not safety events.

The Department's own figures show why that matters. In the two years for which it published the split by Act, roughly one in three OHS Act inspections found non-compliance (35 percent in 2022/23 and 34 percent in 2023/24), against 10 to 11 percent for employment conditions inspections. [4][5] An inspector who opens the safety file is not testing whether you have a consultant. Sections 8 and 16 make the question whether the employer's duties are being discharged, and section 37 makes the answer depend on the records.

Five questions to put to your own arrangement

These are not questions about your consultant's competence. They are questions about the part of the system the Act leaves with you, and each has a yes or no answer.

  • Who holds your section 16(2) assignments, and is each of them a person under the CEO's control with authority over the area named in the letter?
  • Is the arrangement with your consultant in writing, and does it say which tasks are theirs and which decisions stay with the business?
  • Where does the file live, and could your managing director open it, today, without asking the consultant to send it?
  • For every finding raised on the last visit, can you show who closed it, when, and the evidence, in one place?
  • What has changed in the business since the file was last updated: people, premises, equipment, contractors? Is each change reflected in it?

A business that answers yes to all five is in a strong position, and its consultant is very likely the reason. A business that answers no to any one of them has found the gap the Act places on the employer, and it is almost never the consultant's fault.

GRC Shop view

This section is opinion and interpretation, not a statement of law.

Compliance files go stale. Our system keeps yours current. That is not a claim about consultants, whose work is usually right on the day it is done, and it is not a substitute for one. It is a claim about the space between their visits, which is where the Act puts the accountability and where most files quietly fall out of date. Closing out happens in email, evidence scatters across folders, and a year later the report still reads clean while the file no longer matches the business. That is not neglect. It is that nothing holds the pieces together between visits.

The GRC Shop platform does one thing, and its OHS app is currently the only app on it: it keeps a single managed, live record of a business's OHS obligations, appointments, findings and evidence, so that the person the Act holds accountable can see the current position without asking anyone to send it. It works alongside a consultant rather than instead of one: an outside adviser can be given role-based, client-controlled access to work inside the same record without taking the file away from the business. In our view the strongest arrangement is the one the Act already implies: the consultant advises, line managers act, and the record shows both.

If you would like to see what that looks like for your business, request a quote at https://www.grcshop.co.za/get-a-quote

Abbreviations

  • BCEA: Basic Conditions of Employment Act 75 of 1997
  • CEO: chief executive officer
  • OHS: occupational health and safety

References

[1] Republic of South Africa, "Occupational Health and Safety Act 85 of 1993", sections 1 (definition of mandatary), 8, 16 and 37, 1993. https://www.gov.za/sites/default/files/gcis_document/201409/act85of1993.pdf

[2] Labour Guide South Africa, "Legal Role and Responsibilities of the Section 16(1) (CEO) and Section 16(2) Appointees as Stipulated by the Occupational Health and Safety Act", 21 Jun 2023. https://labourguide.co.za/health-and-safety/legal-role-and-responsibilities-of-the-section-161-ceo-and-section-162-appointees-as-stipulated-by-the-occupational-health-and-safety-act

[3] Altra Medical Productions, "Does Appointing a Safety Officer Transfer Management's Legal Liability?", 27 Aug 2026. https://www.altramed.co.za/does-appointing-a-safety-officer-transfer-managements-legal-liability/

[4] Department of Employment and Labour, via the South African Government, "Employment and Labour exceeds its target of inspections for 2022/23 financial year", 20 Sep 2023. https://www.gov.za/news/media-statements/employment-and-labour-exceeds-its-target-inspections-202223-financial-year-20

[5] Department of Employment and Labour, "Department of Employment and Labour Status of Compliance Report highlights the need to improve compliance with labour law", 08 Oct 2024. https://www.labour.gov.za/Media-Desk/Media-Statements/Pages/Department-of-Employment-and-Labour-Status-of-Compliance-Report-highlights-the-need-to-improve-compliance-with-labour-law.aspx

Thirty People, Three Branches: Why Your Safety Thresholds Count Premises, Not Payroll
Almost every South African employer counts its safety obligations off the payroll